I wasn’t going to read this book. It’s not my sort of thing. I don’t particularly like horror, and the setting didn’t interest me. I kept seeing how much other people enjoyed it and watched it garner high-level literary praise. I started to waver. Maybe I should take a look?
When Titan Books offered me the chance to read it, I jumped at it. Particularly as I had thought similarly about Angel Down by Daniel Kraus, which turned out to be the best book I’ve read in a very, very long time.
I figured lightning might strike twice. Well, dear reader, I am here to tell you that it didn’t.
Growing Information:
Plant With: Horror, Vampires, Native Americans.
Grows Into: A fêted horror that left me colder than a vampire’s britches.
Rating: Garage Flowers 🌻 (Check here for rating information.)
Available now in paperback (affiliate link).
Many thanks to Titan Books for sending me a copy of the book.
The Review:
I reiterate, The Buffalo Hunter Hunter has a large following. It is viewed by many as a masterpiece. Not every book is for every person, and for me it just didn’t work.
I didn’t help myself. I took a break partway through reading because I wanted to review Audrey Niffenegger’s Life Out of Order in a timely fashion. I didn’t even pick it back up straight away after that, instead opting to read Witchcraft for Wayward Girls.
When I did return, this broken reading meant I struggled to remember what happened in the first part of the book, losing the sense of the characters and cultures represented. That said, I struggled with this aspect from the beginning, which is why I put it down to read the new Audrey Niffenegger.
I commented on Bluesky that it wasn’t going well, and several people told me that it started slow, but I should persist because the payoff was worth it. Well, I did, and it wasn’t.
The Buffalo Hunter Hunter is a story within a story within a story. A failing modern-day academic is reading the diary of her grandfather from 1912. In that diary, he talks about his own life, but also his encounter with “Good Stab,” an erudite, sunglass-wearing member of the Blackfeet Nation.
Good Stab is essentially a vampire. He and members of the Pikuni tribe are out hunting when they raid a US baggage train (or something, I can’t quite remember). The train is transporting a prisoner, who turns out to be a vampire. He bites Good Stab, and from then on the hunter’s life is never the same again. Mainly because he’s dead. Well, undead.
Through his testament, we learn about his life as he tries to adapt to his newfound predicament. This take on vampirism is intriguing, and it has the added dimension of playing out against the backdrop of settler colonialism and the gradual eradication of the Native American way of life.
The story will ultimately become one of revenge before returning to the present day to add some contemporary scares. Vampires never die, you see; they just lose their bite, or at least this book did.
Why The Buffalo Hunter Hunter left me cold when it’s well loved by others, I’m not sure. I found the narrators uninteresting, both the diarist and Good Stab. The story of a guy stuck in the wilderness being forced to drink the blood of animals for an extended period of time did nothing for me. Neither did the narrative style.
It’s probably a “me” problem, but I’m never a fan of archaic writing style, such as that laid down in the journal, and the Blackfeet terminology left me lost and unable to visualise what animal was being eaten when. For whatever reason, I struggled to decode the text, which meant I was often unsure of what was happening. Where blame lies for this, reader or writer, is hard to determine.
I failed to empathise with any of the book’s characters, even though a terrible, real-world tragedy sits at its centre. Perhaps this is because I’m safely ensconced in the middle-class, sunlit uplands of the United Kingdom and so incapable of empathy, or perhaps the detached narrative style stopped me from empathising with its wider events.
I found the horror elements unsettling, perhaps, but ultimately so ridiculous, I couldn’t help but eye-roll (to reveal why would be a spoiler – besides, perhaps you’ll be properly horrified). I was desperate to be done with the book. By the end, if somebody wanted to put me out of my misery by drinking my blood, I’d probably have welcomed the oblivion.

Leave a Reply